KELOWNA — A wage increase of nearly 12 per cent for City of Kelowna staff was approved just before the October municipal election but only announced publicly afterward. The deal was ratified on October 19, two days after voters went to the polls. The outgoing city council was informed of the negotiations, but no public announcement was made before the election. Residents learned of the pay raise through subsequent media coverage, prompting criticism about transparency.
Gage Haubrich, a director with the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, said the process failed taxpayers. "Taxpayers shouldn’t be learning how much stuff costs from reporters. This kind of transparency should really be the bare minimum standard for cities," Haubrich said. He argued the city should have informed residents in advance about the proposal and its financial impact. At the very least, he said, the city should have issued a news release.
City negotiator Stuart Leatherdale, the general manager of people and protective services, said there was an agreement with CUPE not to involve the media during bargaining. That understanding held throughout the negotiation and ratification process. Leatherdale acknowledged the public's frustration over the lack of an announcement. "I think it’s a fair comment, and I’ll accept that from the general public," he said.
Leatherdale noted the city has previously issued joint news releases with unions about labour agreements. "Normally, when we have done that in the past, it’s by joint agreement. We both put that statement out," he said. "We just never did get to making that agreement this time around." Following the media reports, the city published a "For the Record" release to dispute some information and add context about the negotiations.
That post is part of a series of after-the-fact statements on the city's website. Another recent release saw the city manager defending the municipality's transparency record. Sean Holman, a journalism professor at the University of Victoria, said the city's actions reveal a deeper communication issue. "It is a symptom of a communication problem. It is the symptom of a bureaucratic public relations process that is afraid of sharing facts with the media and by extension with the public," Holman said.
"Constant massaging of image actually does not serve government in the long run. It actually simply makes the government appear less trustworthy," Holman added. When Global News sought interviews on Friday about transparency and communication, neither the mayor, city manager, nor other city hall officials were available to meet the daily news deadline for an on-camera interview. The controversy emerges as Kelowna's re-elected mayor has pledged to improve communication with residents. It is unclear how that promise will change practices at city hall. "It’s an incredibly adversarial approach that the city is taking," Holman said. "What they should be doing is providing facts in a timely manner to journalists, so we can report on stories in a timely manner to the public who we serve, just like the city is supposed to serve."