The Ontario Liberal Party will announce its new leader on Saturday, concluding a months-long race where party insiders say no candidate has emerged as a clear favourite. The result follows two weeks of online voting in which 55,000 party members were eligible to cast a ballot. The party, which governed Ontario for nearly 15 years, has held third-party status in the legislature since its 2018 defeat by Premier Doug Ford’s Progressive Conservatives. The winner will be announced late Saturday afternoon at a party event in Toronto.

Four candidates are vying for the leadership: sitting MPPs Lee Fairclough and Stephanie Bowman, former federal industry minister Navdeep Bains and policy advisor Dylan Marando. Blue Knox, a long-time Liberal strategist, said the outcome is unpredictable. "Nobody knows what the result is going to be," Knox said. "I think that's really healthy for the party. That means there are some real choices in front of voters and the best campaign really is going to win. This wasn't a runaway for anyone."

Bains was considered the front-runner when he entered the race in May, but Knox said the other candidates have improved and impressed party members over the course of the campaign. The party is using a ranked ballot system, which adds another layer of uncertainty to the result. "Crazy things happen on a ranked ballot," Knox said. "If the other candidates manage to garner second and third ballot support, you can never say with 100 per cent certainty if it's going to go to any one candidate."

During the vote, party members ranked the contenders by preference, with votes tallied by riding. Each riding is worth 100 points, divided based on the candidates' support. If no candidate gets more than 50 per cent support on the first ballot, the last-place candidate is eliminated and a second ballot is counted, with rounds continuing until a winner receives majority support. Former Liberal cabinet minister John Milloy said while Bains may have been perceived as the front-runner earlier this year, Fairclough is viewed to have pushed her way into contention with strong organizing and fundraising.

Milloy, now director of the Centre for Public Ethics at Martin Luther University College, said the race is too difficult to call ahead of time. "I don't think any of them are the runaway winner," he said. "I've actually seen a fair amount of caution amongst Liberals. They want to hear people out, they want to kick the tires." He added that none of the campaigns have openly declared how many members they have signed up, making it hard to predict the vote breakdown. "It's about who sold memberships, and we don't always have that sense," Milloy said.

This will be the third new leader for the Liberals since 2018. Former premier Kathleen Wynne resigned after the party's defeat eight years ago, which cost it official party status and the associated funding. Steven Del Duca succeeded her but quit after losing the 2022 election. Bonnie Crombie won the leadership next but resigned last fall after receiving 57 per cent support in a mandatory party review. Under Crombie, the party made gains, increasing its share of the popular vote and winning enough seats to regain official party status.

Liberal strategist Charles Bird said this latest race has been low-key and struggled to break through to regular Ontarians. The candidates have been cordial to each other, agreeing on many policies with few criticisms exchanged. Bird, a principal at Earnscliffe Strategies, said that dynamic has taken some of the spark out of the campaign. "I think everyone wants to be everyone else's second choice, if not the first choice," he said. "Attacking your fellow candidates really doesn't make a lot of sense mathematically." While the candidates have seemed hesitant to criticize each other, they have not held back on Premier Doug Ford and his government. Bird said the campaign has contributed to a broader policy discussion within the party, with some candidates releasing detailed positions on everything from education to economics to online gambling. "There's been a very, very healthy policy discussion, zeroing in on policy areas where Ford and his government are perceived to be weak," he said.