The Bank of Canada and the federal government have renewed the central bank's monetary policy framework, reaffirming a 2 percent inflation target as its primary objective. The agreement, announced on November 5, was welcomed by economists who say it provides a clearer focus than the previous renewal. The 2021 agreement had fuelled speculation the bank was moving toward a dual mandate by explicitly committing it to seek maximum employment. This renewal returns to a singular focus on inflation, a move analysts support after inflation peaked at 8.1 percent in recent years.
"The best contribution the Bank of Canada can make to the economy is targeting low and stable inflation," said Jeremy Kronick, Steve Ambler and Thorsten Koeppl of the C.D. Howe Institute in an analysis. They noted the 2021 agreement lacked clarity and muddied the waters by recognizing other challenges like climate change and inequality. While worthy, they argue central bank tools are poorly suited to addressing those issues directly. The new framework maintains the flexibility of a 1- to 3-percent control range, allowing the bank to adjust the speed at which it returns inflation to target based on economic conditions. The analysts said the bank has already used this flexibility this year, looking through supply shocks from the Middle East conflict that drove energy prices and inflation above 3 percent. The joint announcement stated the bank has strengthened its analytical capacity to better assess how global and domestic supply-side shocks transmit to inflation and how policy should respond when such shocks are larger and more persistent.
However, the announcement did not address two other major questions the bank had indicated it was studying ahead of the renewal. The first is how it should measure and communicate underlying inflation in a more volatile world. The analysts said the bank's current core inflation measures are useful and less volatile than headline inflation, capturing underlying pressure by looking through temporary price changes. They argue that while core inflation is crucial for decisions, the bank should emphasize its inflation forecast and the expected path of its policy interest rate to communicate more effectively with the public.
The second unanswered question concerns housing. The joint statement made no mention of how monetary policy affects housing demand and supply, or how those effects influence inflation in that sector. The C.D. Howe analysts argue the Bank of Canada should not be responsible for addressing Canada's structural housing affordability challenges, as doing so would force it to make distributional choices. They say lower interest rates can reduce borrowing costs but also push up house prices, creating winners and losers. Fiscal and regulatory policies are better suited to tackling structural barriers to housing supply and affordability, according to their analysis.
The background documentation accompanying the renewal has not yet been released. The analysts said this gives the bank a unique opportunity to clarify its thinking on these outstanding questions. By providing clear answers, the bank can reinforce its operational independence, which they describe as essential to fulfilling its mandate. Jeremy Kronick is president and CEO of the C.D. Howe Institute, where Steve Ambler, an emeritus professor of economics at Université du Québec à Montréal, holds the David Dodge Chair in Monetary Policy. Thorsten Koeppl, a professor in the Department of Economics at Queen's University, is a fellow-in-residence at the institute.