Quebecor has made a $31-billion public proposal to buy Telus, a move that would reduce Canada's national wireless carriers from four to three and fold the price-cutting challenger Freedom Mobile into what would become the country's largest telecom company. The bid, made public on Nov. 16, has drawn immediate criticism from competition experts, politicians and Telus's own board, who warn it would undermine the competitive landscape the federal government sought to preserve just three years ago. Quebecor CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau says the deal is "certainly not based on increasing prices," but he would not commit to lowering them at Telus, according to a Radio-Canada report. The proposal comes after Statistics Canada data cited by Quebecor shows wireless prices fell 35.4 per cent between April 2023 and April 2026, a market-wide drop the company says Freedom's aggressive pricing helped drive.

University of Ottawa law professor Michael Geist said the merger would cut competition without changing network ownership and would "unwind the very remedy the government relied upon" to approve the Rogers-Shaw merger. That 2023 deal was approved on the key condition that Shaw's Freedom Mobile be sold to a buyer that would maintain a fourth national carrier, which Quebecor's Vidéotron subsidiary purchased. Competition lawyer Michael Osborne told Global News that combining Telus's market share of just under 30 per cent with Freedom's just under 12 per cent would likely cross the Competition Act threshold where a merger is presumed to substantially lessen competition. Keldon Bester of the Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project said reverting to three major players "would be a disaster."

Telus's board has cited regulatory risk as its top concern, stating Quebecor "has yet to explain how what it is proposing could be approved." The board also objected to the financial terms, noting Telus shareholders would get about 23 per cent of the votes for about 54 per cent of the equity value in the combined company. RBC analyst Drew McReynolds sees a "low probability" the deal survives under current rules. Quebecor has pitched the acquisition as a defence against American control, but all four national carriers are already Canadian-owned.

The merger would also impact home internet competition. In Quebec, Telus is one of the few challengers to dominant provider Vidéotron and Bell. In British Columbia and Alberta, Telus owns the local fibre lines, while Freedom has been competing with a 5G home internet service for its mobile customers. A merger would place that rival service under Telus's control. The conditions Ottawa attached to the Rogers-Shaw deal included a 10-year bar on Vidéotron transferring Freedom's licences, intended to keep Freedom independent of the big three carriers. A Telus takeover would honour the letter of that condition while defeating its purpose, analysts note.

Industry Minister Mélanie Joly said the Competition Bureau and the CRTC will review the deal, adding, "We will not predetermine the outcomes of the reviews." NDP Leader Avi Lewis was more direct, stating, "We should be breaking up the telecom monopolies, not adding another." Prime Minister Mark Carney offered a contrasting view while speaking to reporters in China, suggesting that, depending on market structure, an oligopoly "can lead to more competition with fewer players." The federal government has tools to block the merger, including the Competition Bureau's authority to challenge it and Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada's power to approve any transfer of Telus's spectrum licences, the same power used to force the sale of Freedom Mobile.

Critics point to the aftermath of the Rogers-Shaw merger as a cautionary tale. After Rogers took over Shaw, it raised its connection fee three times in 13 months, from $60 to $80. A Globe and Mail analysis found more than 3,000 Rogers or former Shaw employees lost their jobs or left in 2023, the year of the merger, though Rogers says it has since filled about 2,600 of the 3,000 Western Canada jobs it promised. Telus itself has opposed Quebecor's growth in the past, going to court in 2021 to try to stop Vidéotron from buying 5G spectrum and lobbying in 2022 to slow the Rogers-Shaw deal while pushing for Globalive, not Vidéotron, to buy Freedom.