MONTREAL — Astronomers have discovered a strange triple-star system roughly 28 light-years from Earth, a finding that challenges expectations about stellar evolution and orbital stability. The system, named Welopō'ai, contains a red dwarf and two white dwarfs, one orbiting extremely close to the red dwarf and the other much farther out. The international team, led by researchers at the University of Montreal's Trottier Institute for Research on Exoplanets, published their findings this week in the journal Astronomy & Astrophysics. "It's a freak thing. It was an annoying object," said Étienne Artigau, a researcher at the institute. "It's not what we were looking for."
The astronomers were initially searching for exoplanets around a star known as IRAS 21500+5903, which was thought to be a binary system. Using the SPIRou instrument at the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope in Hawaii, they measured the red dwarf's velocity and found it was changing by nearly 16 kilometres per second, a huge difference that broke Artigau's analysis code. "At some point, we said, Okay, we should get to the end of it. Something's wrong with that object," Artigau said. The team considered the possibility of a brown dwarf or a black hole causing the perturbations.
Further observations with the Gemini North telescope's 'Alopeke instrument revealed the source: a faint, previously unseen white dwarf orbiting just two astronomical units from the red dwarf, a distance similar to that between the sun and Mars. A second white dwarf orbits the pair from about 1,000 astronomical units away. The inner white dwarf orbits the red dwarf, while the outer white dwarf orbits that pair. What surprises astronomers is that the inner white dwarf is in a stable orbit, even though it should be spiralling inward toward the red dwarf.
They speculate the distant white dwarf may be stabilizing the orbit, though the mechanism is unknown. "We're saying it cannot exist," Artigau said. "Of course, it exists. It's there." Paul Delaney, professor emeritus of physics and astronomy at York University, suggested the outer white dwarf may have once been much closer. "I would bet that they were relatively proximate to each other and then they did engage in a bit of gravitational embracing," Delaney said.
The system is estimated to be about 10 billion years old, more than twice the age of our solar system, and its stars are metal-rich, which is unusual for stars of that age. "It's tantalizing, and we just don't know if it means anything. It may just be a random draw basically of a stellar population," Artigau said. The team gave the system the Hawaiian name Welopō'ai, combining words for "inherited family trait" and "circular path" to mean "path of family traits."
Before becoming a white dwarf, a star swells into a red giant. The inner white dwarf's progenitor star would have been so close to the red dwarf during this phase that the two should have interacted, potentially merging or one enveloping the other. That this did not happen adds to the system's peculiarity. "It's weird that no one found the system, but it also says that there are weird things overlooked just next to us," Artigau said. "It's like not next door, but down the road, just one block away of a stellar neighbourhood."
While the team did not find an exoplanet, the search is not over. "It's such a weirdo system that Atanas Stefanov, one of the authors, he's applying for time to get, to look for planets around the red dwarf," Artigau said. The discovery of a triple-star system evokes the fictional scenario in the popular "3 Body Problem," where a chaotic three-body system affects a nearby planet. In reality, three-body systems are notoriously unpredictable because each body's gravitational pull constantly alters the motions of the others.
For Artigau, the unexpected discovery was a welcome diversion. "I like it," he said. "Little things that are just sideways in your life in research. It's fun."